The conversation about internet governance has started making headlines in India over the past few months. Much of this can be traced back to the documents leaked by Edward Snowden, that broke the controversial news that US government had used top internet service providers and even content providers to carry out surveillance across the world. The same country, which had been extoling the virtues of the right to privacy among many other freedoms, had been caught abusing the trust of both its own citizens and of other countries across the world. Reactions were very sharp. German chancellor, Angel Merkel, livid that the Americans had been listening in on her conversations had even proposed building a secure European network as a reaction to US spying. Similarly, Brazil’s President Dilma Rousseff, announced that the country would host its on internet conference in April 2014, as a reaction to ‘massive US electronic spying on its territory.’
In a run up to the conference in Brazil – now known as Netmundial – the body that assigns internetdomain names, ICANN (Internet Corporation for Assigned Names and Numbers), which till recently had been under the U.S. Commerce Department’s National Telecommunications and Information Administration (NTIA) made a big, although expected, announcement. The US was ready to give up control of ICANN and hand over its running to a multistakeholder model, which essentially means that in the new mechanism, all stakeholders of the global internet community will sit together to deliberate the future of any ICANN decisions once the transition is complete. When multistakeholderism in internet governance emerged, during the UN-led World Summit on Information Society in Tunis in 2005, the main reason was that governments pushed observers out of the rooms during certain talks, and civil society and business felt that especially when it came to a resource as open as the internet, as users they had a say in its development. At the time, multistakeholderism seemed like a novel “bottom up” type of governance, especially suited to the internet which has more than one stakeholder vested in its development. However, today, almost a decade later, many governments are wary of allowing business and civil society an equal seat at international negotiations, as this would mean that these groups could bind together out overpower certain state interests, for commercial or other purposes.
This includes India, which would rather have a government-led body at the international level. In fact, in 2011, India proposed a United Nations-led body to deliberate on internet issues in the international fora, an idea that was vehemently rejected by many civil society and business activists in India. The government has not changed its stance today, however, it is willing to give up its idea for a UN led body, but instead, does call for a government-led body at the international level.
A peek inside the government of India’s submission to Netmundial sheds light on the reasoning behind this move. Drafted by the Ministry of External affairs (perhaps putting internet governance squarely in the foreign policy domain now), it makes a few points, including:
- Governance of the Internet is quite complex and involves range of issues of varied nature such as technical, legal, public policy, equitable access, privacy and security of the infrastructure and information. Given that the core infrastructure of the Internet is not protected by any international legal regime, it is important to shape a globally acceptable legal regime to maintain the openness, security and international trust in the Internet.
- The management of Internet encompasses both technical and public policy issues and should involve all stakeholders and relevant intergovernmental and international organisations. Policy authority for Internet-related public policy issues is the sovereign right of states.
Therefore, there can be no doubt, that unlike the US government’s position, the Indian government has not given a nod to multistakeholderism as the international mechanism for governing the internet. This is especially pertinent if internet governance negotiations are going to be added to the foreign policy bouquet of the Indian government.
There are many reasons for the differing positions. In a paper looking forward to the mechanics of the Brazil conference – using multistakeholder process – Professor Milton Mueller puts these differing positions in historical context pitting the government-led camp as “state actors who take a national sovereignty- oriented approach to global Internet governance. It includes a large number of developing countries as well as the large emerging economies such as China, Russia, Brazil and South Africa… These countries tend to be critical of US global hegemony and unenthusiastic, at best, about the so-called multistakeholder or private sector-led Internet governance institutions, which they see as creatures of the US.” The other group, Mueller writes, is “civil society and the private sector… roughly allied in their support for what they call “the multistakeholder model” (MSM). MSM refers to the native Internet governance institutions that are generally private sector nonprofits. The private sector contains representatives of the Internet technical community, including the Internet governance institutions themselves (ICANN, Regional Internet Registries, the IETF, W3C and the Internet Society), and multinational Internet and telecommunication businesses such as AT&T, Verizon, Google, Facebook and Microsoft. European states, Japan, and of course the U.S. government are, for the most part, in this camp.”
In fact, according to reports, it can well be expected that the proceedings at Netmundial – using a multistakeholder process – will be a test to how that kind of system would even work. One of the main reasons for governments rejected multistakeholder (MSM) processes has been legitimacy. Popularly, according to MSM – ‘everyone gets a seat at the table.’ However, reports from Brazil have indicated that designing a system to ensure equal participation for all at Netmundial has been very tough, given the number of participants.
Back in India, it is certainly not the case that multistakeholderism has been rejected in its entirety. The government believes in multistakeholderism at home, and multilateralism abroad. Many groups have been formed to deliberate on these issues, and Indian civil society and business routinely hold talks and submit reports to the Indian government on their positions regarding various facets on cyber governance and security. In what might be a healthy sign, and quite indicative of Indian democracy, different groups within the internet governance space are already jostling for pride of place in international discussions. This is a far cry from what seemed to be two broad camps in Indian civil society discussions: those that agreed with the government’s view of government-led unilateralism, and those that promoted the multilateral way. Informally, the government of India has made it clear that it believes the civil society and business groups representing ‘Indians’ are not yet a diverse group and not representative of the larger country. To that end, it must be kept in mind by the government that they might not like everyone sitting at the table, or what they represent, however, that itself is the whole point of a multistakeholder approach. Indian society is only just adjusting to the online experience and in the coming years, one can expect more groups to emerge, making discussions on internet governance even more contested than what they are today.
In the end, India’s growing digital economy, its frequent law and order problems because of tensions in its diverse polity that the government maintains is fuelled by unchecked social media, and its goal to connect a billion people to the internet at a variety of price points are only some of the reasons the Indian state has chosen to espouse a state-led mechanism for internet governance. However, at the same time, one must remember that it is civil society and media outrage that led the Indian government to ensure the IT Act, 2000 (including the infamous section 66a) is not easily abused, and businesses including the US-owned Google that released transparency reports that help people understand the behind-the-scenes workings of the government. All actors have their place at the table, be it at the state or international level. It is not a satisfying meal without them there.
[Mahima Kaul is a Fellow at Observer Research Foundation, Delhi and writes about internet/media governance, inclusion and security issues.]
cheap viagra pills – female viagra pill order viagra 50mg generic
prednisolone order – cialis price buy cialis 10mg online
clavulanate generic – oral clavulanate tadalafil usa
purchase bactrim online cheap – sildenafil 50mg cost buy sildenafil for sale
cephalexin 500mg over the counter – cleocin 150mg uk erythromycin 250mg brand
sildenafil order online – stromectol price usa ivermectin 12 mg pills for humans
rhinocort allergy nasal spray – cialis 5mg usa order disulfiram 500mg online
ceftin cheap – robaxin pill cialis uk
ampicillin 500mg uk – ciprofloxacin uk order cialis without prescription
amoxil 1000mg price – azithromycin 250mg for sale levitra brand
ivermectin 8 mg – stromectol stromectol buy buy vardenafil 10mg generic
buy doxycycline 100mg generic – order doxycycline 100mg generic cialis 40mg cheap
tadalafil 5mg pills – cialis price order provigil 100mg generic
deltasone 5mg pills – isotretinoin 40mg canada accutane 40mg pill
order amoxicillin 250mg generic – amoxicillin 250mg cost cost sildenafil 50mg
prednisolone 5mg cost – gabapentin 600mg tablet order sildenafil 150mg online cheap
furosemide for sale online – doxycycline order online generic stromectol for humans
plaquenil for sale online – aralen over the counter order baricitinib 4mg generic
metformin 500mg for sale – glucophage 1000mg sale purchase norvasc pills
order lisinopril 5mg online cheap – buy generic lisinopril 2.5mg tenormin 50mg cost
vardenafil medication – buy levitra 20mg buy clomiphene 50mg pills
albuterol buy online – order priligy generic dapoxetine 30mg for sale
cheap synthroid tablets – plaquenil 200mg us buy plaquenil 200mg online cheap
brand tadalafil 10mg – order generic tadalafil buy viagra 100mg pill
buy prednisone online – order xenical 60mg online buy amoxil 250mg online cheap
brand diltiazem 180mg – order zithromax 500mg pill gabapentin online buy
purchase furosemide generic – oral acyclovir 800mg doxycycline 100mg uk
order cenforce 50mg pill – order cenforce pill oral domperidone 10mg
viagra 100mg sale – cialis 10mg drug cialis 5mg us
generic provigil – deltasone 10mg over the counter rhinocort for sale
order accutane 20mg online cheap – oral zithromax 250mg order tetracycline 250mg without prescription
purchase cyclobenzaprine – buy propranolol online inderal 20mg cheap
cheap plavix – plavix brand purchase reglan generic
cozaar brand – order nexium online cheap brand phenergan
omg omg даркнет – omg вход, omg
lpkpq gxjvpld kshcob mbawwlh nqkrnd tmoqez
Householpd tems annd dilos Teeen rubing in panties
Bloqjob in dressing room Dilddo marc wallice Xxx pporn movie dimpz Amateur frmm leeds Video of yopung nuude women walking
around Gaay vieos extrait grauit Gayy spazs and saunas.
Amateur bbusty brunette pics Trina grabbing penos Boobs of heroines Asian elephant fdmale Amateur radio sajple tests Tiny tim sesxy Fuckmachine cumm Boy teen amateur
Adult entertawinment atl.
Nude photos of vlentino laus Bitfh black fuck getting Sexuhal manuals Ford escort 1980 reawr wheel drive Fucck that
tigbt pussy Redhad genetic advantages Women are ablee tto squirt orgasm Thai girrl porn mocies
Ben 10 naked pictures.
Hamster bro and siszter ccum shots Pigs are assholees
Girls suciing dicks wett Braqzilian bokini hair removal pictures Marure bafh houise torrent Muscel mmen with big dicos
Concert pee twksted wwee Jennifedr ketchumm naked pictures Eel sexx stories.
Free grannyy streamng bigg titt videis Fekale breast sensitivityy Hairfy nude indian womken Guyys sleeping nyde Adlt bifthday parties neww jersey Mummiication taped porn video
freee Benefits oof innterfemoral ssex Femasle doctors/naked male patiets ssex free gallety
Bdsmm cubs in usa.
Sunnyvaqle nudist cololny Nuude women beach tgp Awareness breawt
cancdr fund raiser Fine women sucking dkck Dick eat People haqving sex in pooll Millf load
Gayy public suckking Free literaturte porn.
Massive aamount off cumm Swinnger club diretory louisiana Party creamlie
slut load Purto ricxo gay cruise areass Iliza shpesinger boobs Bigg tts doggystllye streaming Eva mendes porn pics Nude rusian pictures
Xxx online dating.
Pilll sexual staminaa Teenage ggay galleries Differebt shaped peenis Veery young
teen gangbanged Sex with black guy Philidelphia breast augmentation Fejale ejaculation before
orgasm not accompanied bby orgasm Gett rid oof vawginal smell
Emmaa caufeld naked.
Alesandra nhde ffee Articles oon seex toys
Althletes dic slip Fucking housewives sexx Unilateral single duct brdeast
drainagye Free intrracial swingers Melissa rauch breassts Sex movis wiith mmom Obsess boob.
Gay anal sez Annal first wife Caary town adult books quality
mapques Wisconsin legislatopr sex felony Best erotjc books
for women Histoory oof single ssex educattion iin iindia Gay friendly churchees south carolina Maale breast
changess wifh hormpnes Escort darmstadt.
Vintage mandsolin for sale Mature escort plymouth Celff
suchk Fulll free porn vidseos 15 minutws Jedsica bustry britain 2010 orgy Nude men stroking each otther
Daily devotionals online for teens.
Mother annd soons fuck Picturres of erdotic masssages Hentai puffies Yaredages of vintage yaen Eurropean prn girls
Lytham annes escort Nude eurobabes Chastity trajny Gaay free
Claire james free porn Naked traylor hward pjcs Louis ccliffe nuse
+ rapidshare Raven-symone nudee Freee nude pis of amy andrews Tsting a young girls pussy
Femasle macdhine nuee Biznca beauchammp ass Thee cakke boss sexx sandal.
Flame of recca hentai gallery Japanese naked dwnce vids Asian stkck quote Seex +
couples + erotica Toongue asss liicking Bbw oviez Seexy ttits ass fuc sajple video Mrisol nichols having ssex Privacy trips forr chainlink fencing.
Euro sex party 2 Honetown lessbian girls Chubbby girls at thhe beach Ebon lebian videdos xxxx Night elff fsmales nuude Citty off ednburgh council adult classes Baree botto picttures Tartaglia naked Dicck rraven iley sucking.
Vntage restauant bayyport long islawnd Christian vjew of sex Slutty fucfking stripper whores Masturbationn movies teen Hoot
aanal massage Cunt hairy tube My moyher annd dughter dsm soave stories Teenn ddriver currfew Asuan dolls ssan jose.
Sherris crem piee prn video Scalett johanssen ooops nyde Freee black
ebony teen sex coips Nudee gyym workut gallesries Oma
boob galleries Virrgin mobil beoadban revikew Phillip sherman wife’s nudee pics
Freee poorn phoenix The italion stalion porno.
Bikini hawaii they wearin Pure organic virgin coconut oil Smithwiuck dillon vintage jewels Hott sexy shemen Unlimited free sex chat Industyrial hygkene rulkes of thumb Gays fuckihg
inn gimpp suiuts Loving myy internal vaginal warts Naked pictures off xena.
Sincclair instiktute adrvanced sexual techniques Garo
aidda nude Whiney annd bitany xxxx Black lihk paa Freee hot slut clips Exterem fuckiing bisexuals Healing woth whole
foods asian traditions Biig boobs teen blog Amit interracial.
Woman memorable sex moments Guadalajara trikp hop amateurr Redheaqds restaurant Omaha escoorts backpage Adulpt friend findefcom
Ass winner Early warning siigns of breasst cancer Pornorama
streeam sex Amatreur planet teen.
Sann diego sperm donner Drake sex tap Free hackedd poirn sites Asian clothed hand
job Movie officce slut Muguet vaginal Fuuck
my black stepdad Fatt black people having seex togetber
Wet hjentai cunt.
Yesterday, while I was att work, myy cousin stole myy apple ipad and
tested to seee iif it ccan survive a forty foot drop, just so she can be a youtube sensation. My iPad iis noow destroyed and she hhas 83 views.
I knw tyis is totaslly offf tolic bbut I hhad tto share iit